Phở bò (Vietnamese beef noodle soup)

Vietnam's national soul in a bowl: eight hours of bone broth perfumed with star anise, coriander seed, and charred ginger, finished at the table with a bright tangle of fresh herbs.

Origin: Hanoi, Vietnam

From the journey of Coriander/Cilantro.

Phở originated in Nam Định province and Hanoi in the early 20th century, likely in the first decade of the 1900s, and possibly influenced by French pot-au-feu, the word phở may derive from feu (fire). It became the definitive breakfast food of Northern Vietnam, eaten from street carts and specialist restaurants from dawn, and was carried globally by the Vietnamese diaspora after 1975. Coriander plays a dual role: coriander seeds are toasted and added to the broth at the very beginning, giving it a warm, citrusy, slightly floral depth; fresh coriander leaves (ngò rí) arrive raw at the end, scattered over the bowl as part of the herb plate alongside Thai basil, bean sprouts, and fresh chilli. The herb plate, from which each diner customises their own bowl: makes coriander's role visible and intentional. The broth is everything in phở: the long, slow extraction of collagen, marrow, and aromatics from beef bones is what distinguishes a great phở from a merely good one. Treat it as a project.

Ingredients

broth

  • 2 kg beef bones (knuckle, marrow bones, and/or neck bones), a mix gives the best result
  • 500 g beef brisket or beef shin (whole piece)
  • 1 large white onion, halved through the root
  • 1 large knob of fresh ginger (about 10cm), halved lengthways
  • 2 tbsp fish sauce (nước mắm), plus more to taste
  • 1 tbsp rock sugar or white sugar
  • 2 tsp fine sea salt, plus more to taste
  • 3 litres cold water

broth spices

  • 3 whole star anise
  • 1 stick cassia bark or cinnamon (about 8cm)
  • 4 whole cloves
  • 1 tbsp coriander seeds, toasted in a dry pan until fragrant
  • 1 tsp fennel seeds
  • 1 tsp black peppercorns

noodles and beef

  • 400 g dried flat rice noodles (bánh phở, 3–5mm wide)
  • 400 g beef eye fillet (tenderloin) or sirloin, very thinly sliced against the grain, partially freeze for 30 minutes for easier slicing

herb plate

  • 1 large bunch fresh coriander (ngò rí), leaves and fine stems only
  • 1 large bunch Thai basil (húng quế)
  • 200 g fresh bean sprouts
  • 2 whole fresh red or green chillies, thinly sliced
  • 2 whole limes, cut into wedges

garnish

  • 4 whole spring onions (scallions), thinly sliced
  • 1 small handful fried shallots (optional)

condiments

  • 1 bottle hoisin sauce, to serve at the table
  • 1 bottle sriracha or chilli sauce, to serve at the table

Method

  1. Blanch the bones: place the beef bones in a large stockpot, cover with cold water, and bring to a vigorous boil. Boil hard for 10 minutes: a large amount of grey scum will rise to the surface. Drain, then rinse each bone under cold running water. Wash the pot. This step is essential for a clean, clear broth.
  2. Char the aromatics: hold the onion halves and ginger pieces directly over a gas flame with tongs, or place cut-side-down under a very hot grill/broiler, until deeply charred and blackened on the cut surfaces: about 5 minutes. Do not burn the ginger to ash; char it. The charring adds a smoky sweetness to the broth that is non-negotiable in authentic phở.
  3. Toast the spices: in a dry frying pan over medium heat, toast the star anise, cassia bark, cloves, coriander seeds, fennel seeds, and peppercorns together for 2–3 minutes, tossing constantly, until fragrant. Do not burn them. Transfer to a muslin spice bag or tie in a square of cheesecloth.
  4. Build the broth: return the blanched bones to the clean stockpot. Add the brisket or shin as a whole piece. Add the charred onion, charred ginger, and spice bag. Pour over 3 litres of cold water. Bring to a boil, then immediately reduce to the gentlest possible simmer: just a few bubbles breaking the surface every few seconds.
  5. Simmer for 1.5 hours, then carefully remove the brisket/shin. It should be cooked through but not falling apart. Set aside to cool, then wrap and refrigerate. Continue simmering the bones for a further 5–6 hours, skimming the surface occasionally.
  6. After the full broth cooking time, strain through a fine sieve lined with muslin. Discard the solids. You should have approximately 2–2.5 litres of clear, amber-gold broth. Season with fish sauce, sugar, and salt: taste carefully. The broth should be deeply savoury, subtly sweet, and fragrant with star anise and coriander.
  7. Prepare the noodles according to the packet instructions: typically soaking in cold water for 20–30 minutes, then blanching in boiling water for 30–60 seconds until tender but still with slight bite. Drain and divide between deep bowls.
  8. Slice the chilled cooked brisket thinly across the grain. Arrange a few slices of brisket and several slices of the raw beef fillet over the noodles in each bowl. The raw beef will cook in the hot broth.
  9. Bring the strained broth back to a full rolling boil. Ladle the boiling broth generously over each bowl: enough to cover the noodles and beef completely. The boiling broth will cook the raw beef slices instantly.
  10. Garnish each bowl with sliced spring onions and fried shallots if using. Serve immediately with the herb plate arranged in the centre of the table: fresh coriander, Thai basil, bean sprouts, sliced chilli, lime wedges, hoisin, and sriracha. Each diner builds their own bowl.

Notes

The broth is a multi-hour project and is best made a day ahead (the flavour deepens overnight and the fat can be removed after chilling. The recipe produces enough broth for 4–6 generous servings; extra broth freezes well for up to 3 months. Quick weeknight version: use 1.5 litres of good-quality beef stock as the base, simmer with the charred aromatics and spice bag for 1 hour) a respectable shortcut. Phở gà (chicken phở): substitute chicken carcasses for beef bones and a whole chicken for the brisket; reduce simmering time to 2–3 hours. The coriander seed and fresh coriander leaf roles remain identical.

The Gastrographer

The Gastrographer

Mapping Culinary History

To explore — select an ingredient below.

Journey Point Map Key

Ingredient originTrade or transit route
Became a culinary stapleColonial / trade control
c. 1900 CE
Drag to explore journey
14 of 14 stops
1900 CE
5000 BCE100 BCE1300 CE1900 CE
Coriander/Cilantro

Coriander/Cilantro

Coriandrum sativum

Spices & AromaticsHerbsApiaceae

🌍Origin

Fertile Crescent, Levant — c. 5000 BCE

🌱Domestication

Coriander is one of the very oldest of all cultivated plants, and one of the strangest, for it is in truth two ingredients housed within a single species. Coriandrum sativum, a slender annual of the carrot and celery family, the Apiaceae, yields both the warm, citrus-scented dried seed that the English-speaking world calls coriander and the pungent, polarising fresh leaf that the Americas call cilantro, and these two forms, drawn from one plant, have such utterly different flavours that they belong to entirely separate culinary traditions and are seldom thought of as the same thing at all. The whole plant is edible, from the aromatic root that the Thai kitchen pounds into curry pastes, through the lacy fresh leaves, to the round ripe seeds, and this versatility has carried it into the cooking of almost every inhabited region of the earth. The plant's antiquity in human hands is documented across the ancient Near East. Seeds of C. sativum have been recovered from Neolithic deposits in the Levant dating to around 6000 BCE, amongst them the celebrated finds from the Nahal Hemar cave in the Judean Desert, and the plant is named in the ancient Egyptian Ebers Papyrus of around 1550 BCE, the oldest surviving medical compendium of the world. Coriander seeds were even laid in the tomb of Tutankhamun amongst the provisions intended to sustain the pharaoh through eternity, a mark of the value placed upon a plant that was at once food, medicine, and fragrance. Because the plant grows readily from seed and the dried fruits store and travel well, coriander spread early and far, and unlike many spices it was domesticated not in a single remote place but across the broad arc of the Fertile Crescent, where its wild ancestors grew. The dual use of the plant was present from the very beginning of its cultivation, and it is this that sets coriander apart from almost every other ancient culinary herb. In the Levantine cradle the seeds were ground into spice mixtures and steeped into medicinal and fermented drinks, whilst the fresh leaves were gathered as a green herb for the table, so that a single sowing yielded both a warm baking spice and a sharp, fresh garnish. That doubleness has shaped its entire history: the seed travelled west into Europe as a spice of bread and brewing and a medicine for the digestion, whilst the leaf travelled into the kitchens of Mexico, Vietnam, Thailand, India, and North Africa as one of the most essential, and most divisive, of all fresh herbs.

Global Voyage

From its Levantine cradle coriander travelled outward in every direction at once, for the Fertile Crescent sat at the crossroads of three continents, and the dried seed, light, durable, and easily carried, moved along every trade route that left the region. The southwestern path led into Egypt, where the plant was cultivated throughout the Nile Delta within centuries of its domestication and recorded in the Ebers Papyrus as both medicine and flavouring; from Egypt it passed westward along the North African shore and, in time, far south across the Sahara into West Africa, carried on the same caravan routes that bore gold and salt. The eastern path was the longest and the most consequential. Coriander moved along the Silk Road and the Indian Ocean trade into Persia, where it entered the great herb stews of the Iranian kitchen, and into India, where it became, in seed and leaf alike, the single most widely used flavouring of the subcontinent, the backbone of garam masala and the green finish of almost every dish. From India and Persia the plant continued eastward into China, reaching the Han court by way of the Silk Road and the diplomatic missions to Central Asia, where it became the fragrant herb xiangcai of the northern and Muslim kitchens. The western and northern path carried coriander into the classical Mediterranean. The Greeks received it through their trade with Egypt and the Levant and set down its medicinal virtues in the writings of Hippocrates and Dioscorides; the Romans cooked with it lavishly, Apicius calling for it in scores of recipes, and the Roman legions then carried the seed across the whole of the empire, planting it in the cold soils of Gaul, Britain, and the Rhine and Danube frontiers where it had never grown before. Archaeobotanists have recovered Roman-period coriander from sites as far apart as Wales and the Danube, and the Carolingian emperor Charlemagne ordered it grown on every royal estate, ensuring its unbroken survival through the early medieval centuries into the permanent repertoire of the European kitchen. The Arab expansion then carried coriander deep into the Maghreb, where it fused with the indigenous Berber herb traditions of Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia to produce the chermoula and the spice blends of the North African table. In Southeast Asia, reached by the maritime spice routes and the spread of Indian culinary influence, coriander took a wholly distinct path, for there it was the root rather than the seed or leaf that became prized, pounded into the curry pastes of Thailand and the broths of Vietnam. The final great dispersal came with the Spanish conquest of the Americas in the sixteenth century: Spanish colonisers carried the seed across the Atlantic, and the fresh leaf integrated so swiftly and so completely into the indigenous cooking of Mexico, already built upon chillies, tomatoes, tomatillos, and avocado, that within a single generation cilantro had become inseparable from Mexican food, and from there it spread down the Pacific coast of South America into the ceviche of Peru and northward, in the twentieth century, into the everyday cooking of the United States. No other plant has achieved so nearly universal a culinary adoption across every inhabited continent.

🍽Modern Culinary Role

Coriander is at once the most widely consumed fresh herb in the world and one of its most widely used spices, a double distinction that no other plant can claim, and it owes that reach to the fact that its seed and its leaf are, in flavour and in use, two separate ingredients drawn from a single plant. The dried seed, warm, citrus-scented, and gently sweet, is foundational to the spice blends of an entire hemisphere: it is a leading note in the garam masala and curry powders of India, in the dukkah and baharat of the Arab world, in the ras el hanout and chermoula of North Africa, and in the recados and adobos of Latin America, and it flavours the breads, sausages, pickles, and brewed drinks of Europe besides. The fresh leaf, pungent and bright and unmistakable, is essential to the cooking of Mexico, where it finishes nearly every salsa, taco, and pot of beans; to Vietnam and Thailand, where it crowns the herb plate and the noodle bowl; to India, where chopped dhania patta finishes almost every dish; and to the soups and stews of West Africa. Yet coriander is also the most divisive of all common herbs, for a significant minority of people, the proportion varying by population, perceive the fresh leaf not as fragrant but as harshly soapy or metallic, an aversion now traced to inherited variants of an olfactory receptor gene that change how its aldehydes are smelled. This genuine genetic divide gives coriander a notoriety no other herb shares, dividing tables and even whole regions, as in China, where the north embraces it and much of the Cantonese south avoids it. For all that, the plant remains indispensable across the greater part of the world, the rare ingredient that supplies both a warm baking spice and a sharp green garnish, and that finishes the everyday food of more people, on more continents, than almost any other plant in the kitchen.

© 2026 The Gastrographer. All original research, narratives, and illustrations. All rights reserved.